Draft opinion from Justice Taney

Item

“Draft Opinion from Justice Taney”. United States Supreme Court Case, 1854-1856, 1857, St. Louis Circuit Court Historical Records Project, accessed October 3, 2026, https://digitalexhibits.library.washu.edu/s/ccr/item/108783

Description
Handwritten revisions to printer's proof
Date
1857-04
Is Part Of
United States Supreme Court Case, 1854-1856
Identifier
dre1854.0000.127
Case ID
ccr1854.0000.002
Source
National Archives and Records Association, Records of the Supreme Court of the United States, Apellate Case File No. 3230
NAID: 236678084
Rights
Public Domain
Transcription
**Item Page 1**

> Image file: 0040_M2013-01-0040.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 2**

> Image file: 0041_M2013-01-0041.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 3**

> Image file: 0042_M2013-01-0042.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 4**

> Image file: 0043_M2013-01-0043.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 5**

> Image file: 0044_M2013-01-0044.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 6**

> Image file: 0045_M2013-01-0045.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 7**

> Image file: 0046_M2013-01-0046.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 8**

> Image file: 0047_M2013-01-0047.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 9**

> Image file: 0048_M2013-01-0048.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 10**

> Image file: 0049_M2013-01-0049.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 11**

> Image file: 0050_M2013-01-0050.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 12**

> Image file: 0051_M2013-01-0051.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 13**

> Image file: 0052_M2013-01-0052.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 14**

> Image file: 0053_M2013-01-0053.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 15**

> Image file: 0054_M2013-01-0054.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 16**

> Image file: 0055_M2013-01-0055.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 17**

> Image file: 0056_M2013-01-0056.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 18**

> Image file: 0057_M2013-01-0057.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 19**

> Image file: 0058_M2013-01-0058.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 20**

> Image file: 0059_M2013-01-0059.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 21**

> Image file: 0060_M2013-01-0060.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 22**

> Image file: 0061_M2013-01-0061.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 23**

> Image file: 0062_M2013-01-0062.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 24**

> Image file: 0063_M2013-01-0063.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 25**

> Image file: 0064_M2013-01-0064.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 26**

> Image file: 0065_M2013-01-0065.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 27**

> Image file: 0066_M2013-01-0066.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 28**

> Image file: 0067_M2013-01-0067.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 29**

> Image file: 0068_M2013-01-0068.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 30**

> Image file: 0069_M2013-01-0069.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 31**

> Image file: 0070_M2013-01-0070.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 32**

> Image file: 0071_M2013-01-0071.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 33**

> Image file: 0072_M2013-01-0072.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 34**

> Image file: 0073_M2013-01-0073.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 35**

> Image file: 0074_M2013-01-0074.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 36**

> Image file: 0075_M2013-01-0075.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 37**

> Image file: 0076_M2013-01-0076.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 38**

> Image file: 0077_M2013-01-0077.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 39**

> Image file: 0078_M2013-01-0078.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 40**

> Image file: 0079_M2013-01-0079.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 41**

> Image file: 0080_M2013-01-0080.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 42**

> Image file: 0081_M2013-01-0081.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 43**

> Image file: 0082_M2013-01-0082.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 44**

> Image file: 0083_M2013-01-0083.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 45**

> Image file: 0084_M2013-01-0084.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 46**

> Image file: 0085_M2013-01-0085.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 47**

> Image file: 0086_M2013-01-0086.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 48**

> Image file: 0087_M2013-01-0087.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 49**

> Image file: 0088_M2013-01-0088.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 50**

> Image file: 0089_M2013-01-0089.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 51**

> Image file: 0090_M2013-01-0090.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 52**

> Image file: 0091_M2013-01-0091.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 53**

> Image file: 0092_M2013-01-0092.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 54**

> Image file: 0093_M2013-01-0093.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 55**

> Image file: 0094_M2013-01-0094.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 56**

> Image file: 0095_M2013-01-0095.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 57**

> Image file: 0096_M2013-01-0096.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 58**

> Image file: 0097_M2013-01-0097.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 59**

> Image file: 0098_M2013-01-0098.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 60**

> Image file: 0099_M2013-01-0099.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]

---

**Item Page 61**

> Image file: 0100_M2013-01-0100.jpg
> Document: Draft opinion from Justice Taney

[Start transcription here]
Title
Draft opinion from Justice Taney

“Draft Opinion from Justice Taney”. United States Supreme Court Case, 1854-1856, 1857, St. Louis Circuit Court Historical Records Project, accessed October 3, 2026, https://digitalexhibits.library.washu.edu/s/ccr/item/108783